The Hard Drive Productions, Inc. v. Does 1-1,495 (Case No. 1:11-cv-01741) case in the District of Columbia has been dead for almost a month now, and Prenda Law Inc. (now the “Anti-Piracy Law Group”) is still calling each and every dismissed defendant as if the case were still alive.
In my opinion, these calls to dismissed defendants are indeed very concerning. The threat is that unless a dismissed defendant settled, they will immediately name and serve them in the federal court in their home state.
HOW TO CHECK WHETHER THEIR THREATS HAVE ANY MERIT
I have literally been hearing about these threats from dismissed defendants for weeks, and there is a VERY EASY way to test whether their threats have merit or not — simply check to see whether Hard Drive Productions, Inc. has filed lawsuits naming individuals. The easiest way to do this is to visit http://www.rfcexpress.com, scroll down on the right-hand side, and check only the “copyright” button. Type “Hard Drive Productions” into the “Party Name” field, click submit, and you’ll see the last state and the last date they filed suit against defendants. [As of 6:45pm on 1/16/2013, there have been ABSOLUTELY NO FILINGS by Hard Drive Productions, Inc. since they tried to sue defendants here in the Southern District of Texas using Doug McIntyre as their local counsel — and you know how badly that ended for them.]
SHOULD YOU CALL THEM?
Now this should be common sense, but you NEVER want to be calling the attorney who is threatening to sue you. Especially when you already know that their game is to extort and solicit settlements from those they believe they can scare into settling.
CAN THEY FOLLOW-UP ON THEIR THREAT AND SUE YOU INDIVIDUALLY?
Obviously Prenda Law Inc. (now the “Anti-Piracy Law Group”) has the capacity to name and serve many individuals in many states. However, they are lawyers just as we are lawyers. And, whatever Prenda Law Inc. does on behalf of a client, somebody needs to pay the bill (especially if there is local counsel involved). If they are suing on behalf of Hard Drive Productions, Inc., then Hard Drive Productions, Inc. needs to pay their bills (or, you do by way of your settlements). Lawsuits are not cheap for a plaintiff, and the up-front cost of filing one ($350 per lawsuit), plus all the time drafting and responding to motions in front of a judge for each case is quite an undertaking.
SHOULD YOU SETTLE?
Thus, if you have no reason to settle, then don’t settle. If you see that they are naming and serving individuals, then contact one of us lawyers. Depending on your circumstances and if I can figure out a way for you to fight your case without settling, that might be the cheaper alternative. Just please don’t try to respond to their calls thinking that you’ll negotiate your way out of this. The only way to get out of this is to back them into a financial corner forcing them to drop your case, defend your case on the merits, or to pay them to make the case go away. I like any option that does not include sending them a check.
CONTACT FORM: If you have a question or comment about what I have written, and you want to keep it *for my eyes only*, please feel free to use the form below. The information you post will be e-mailed to me, and I will be happy to respond.
NOTE: No attorney client relationship is established by sending this form, and while the attorney-client privilege (which keeps everything that you share confidential and private) attaches immediately when you contact me, I do not become your attorney until we sign a contract together. That being said, please do not state anything “incriminating” about your case when using this form, or more practically, in any e-mail.
6 thoughts on “Hard Drive Productions lawsuit is DEAD and Prenda attorneys still calling.”
I am SHOCKED just SHOCKED that Pretenda would do something like this… okay maybe not.
What?! Never. Prenda would never stoop this low…
Jerks. I hope no one falls for these fools.
Yo Cashman, we have all come a long way since 2010. Perhaps by 2013 this will all be a footnote in the history of douchebaggery. And John will be up for parole.
We certainly have. My favorite part of doing this has been the teamwork we (meaning you, me, the others on Twitter, Ernesto at TorrentFreak, SJD, DTD, the EFF, and the other attorneys) have all shared. A year or so ago, John Steele called all of us the “echo chamber.” If he was right, then we have all sang a loud song and have helped not only THOUSANDS of internet users, but we have also helped to shape the law of many districts it applies to internet users, bittorrent, and IP addresses. I look forward to all of us sharing stories once these cases are all done.
Thought Prenda, or whatever these bottome feeders are calling themselves now, is in hot water with the courts?
The trouble they are in is not even described the the happenings in the Florida case. Their whole AF Holdings, LLC fake “Alan Cooper” issue is about to cause some problems for them as well.